Summers Calls Trump's Tariff Emergency Powers 'Problematic' as Supreme Court Prepares to Hear Case

Thursday Nov 6 2025 00:00

Duration

2 min

  1. 1. Summers Criticizes Trump's Use of Emergency Powers for Tariffs

  2. 1.1 Legal Basis for Tariffs Questioned

  3. 1.2 Trump Administration's Supreme Court Defense

  4. 1.3 Broad Definition of Emergency

  5. 1.4 Scope of Presidential Power in Trade

  6. 1.5 Tariffs Not the Right Tool

  7. 1.6 Suggested Solutions

  8. 1.7 Doubt over Emergency Justification

Summers Criticizes Trump's Use of Emergency Powers for Tariffs

Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers has weighed in on President Trump's use of emergency powers to impose tariffs, as the Supreme Court prepares to hear a case challenging the legality of those actions. Summers argues that Trump's reliance on emergency powers in this context is "deeply problematic."

Legal Basis for Tariffs Questioned

Summers stated in an interview that the circumstances cited by Trump to justify the tariffs “don’t really reflect some kind of extraordinary event like 9/11 or the collapse of the dollar.” He further noted, “If this is the right thing to do, the president ought to be able to persuade Congress and get it done through due process.”

Trump Administration's Supreme Court Defense

The Trump administration is set to argue before the Supreme Court on Wednesday that the president has the authority under a 1977 law to impose sweeping tariffs in response to dire situations, including the national trade deficit and the widespread deaths and addiction related to fentanyl imports.

Broad Definition of Emergency

“If it’s simply that the president is worried about the current economic situation and wants to use tariffs as a tool, to define that as an emergency is pretty problematic given our democratic traditions,” said Summers, a Harvard professor and Bloomberg Television contributor.

Scope of Presidential Power in Trade

Critics point out that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not explicitly authorize the president to use tariffs to address the conditions cited by the government, and that trade issues fall under the purview of Congress, not the executive branch.

Tariffs Not the Right Tool

Summers added that, legal arguments aside, the tariffs implemented during Trump's second term are not the right tool to address the long-term decline of American manufacturing, the fiscal deficit, or foreign debt.

Suggested Solutions

Speaking on addressing the US reliance on foreign capital imports, which is the flip side of other countries’ trade surpluses with the US, he stated, “The right measures would involve reducing budget deficits, raising the nation’s saving rate.”

Doubt over Emergency Justification

The former Treasury Secretary concluded, “It’s hard to argue that there is something about the economic situation today that we haven’t seen for most of the last 25 years, that rises to the level of justifying the use of emergency powers.”

Risk Warning: This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, investment research, or a recommendation to trade. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Markets.com. When considering shares, indices, forex (foreign exchange), and commodities for trading and price predictions, remember that trading CFDs involves a significant degree of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Leveraged products can result in capital loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Before trading, ensure you fully understand the risks involved and consider your investment objectives and level of experience. Cryptocurrency CFD trading restrictions may apply depending on jurisdiction.

Default Author Avatar

Written by:

Noah Lee

Asset List

View Full List
Most Traded Commodities Indices Crypto Shares Forex
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now
Asset
Sell
Buy
Change (%)

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Trade Now

Latest

View all
crypto

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Duration

6 min

Crypto Prices Today July 24: Bitcoin Steadies Near $65K as ETF Demand Counters Geopolitical Uncertainty
oil price news today

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Duration

3 min

Oil Price News Today: Brent Slips Below $100 as Traders Weigh US-Iran Tensions
USD to JPY exchange rate today

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Duration

4 min

US Treasury Says Yen Is Deeply Undervalued, Urges Bank of Japan to Continue Rate Hikes

Latest news

gold

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Gold Price Today, July 24: Gold Slips to $4,043 as Dollar and Yields Rise

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Nikkei 225 Falls 2.73% as Alphabet AI Costs Shake Japan Tech Stocks

oil

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Brent Crude Holds Near $100 as Red Sea Supply Risks Escalate

South Korea Tightens Rules on Single-Stock Leveraged

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

South Korea Tightens Rules on Single-Stock Leveraged ETFs, Raises Cash Requirement to KRW 30 Million from July 31

intel earnings 2026 q2

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Intel Q2 Revenue Jumps 25% on AI Demand, Beats Estimates as Strong Q3 Outlook Lifts Shares

crypto

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Crypto Prices Today July 24: Bitcoin Steadies Near $65K as ETF Demand Counters Geopolitical Uncertainty

oil price news today

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

Oil Price News Today: Brent Slips Below $100 as Traders Weigh US-Iran Tensions

USD to JPY exchange rate today

Thursday, 23 July 2026

Indices

US Treasury Says Yen Is Deeply Undervalued, Urges Bank of Japan to Continue Rate Hikes

gold

Wednesday, 22 July 2026

Indices

Gold Price Today, July 23: Gold Holds Above $4,100 as Oil Rally Limits Gains

tesla earnings q2 2026

Wednesday, 22 July 2026

Indices

Tesla 2026 Q2 Earnings: Revenue Surges 26% as AI Investments Weigh on Profits and Cash Flow

See all news